I Asked AI to Pick My Coaching Niche

Categorized as Coaching Business, Start a Coaching Business
Woman working on a laptop at her desk, researching her coaching niche

I keep seeing coaches who are stuck on their niche skip the human and go straight to ChatGPT. Which, fair. It’s instant, it never gets sick of the question, and it always sounds like it knows what it’s talking about.

So I tried it on myself. I’ve worked with coaches for 8 years, and I wanted to see what it would say about my own background.

Honestly, the answer was pretty good. Annoyingly good. But when I looked closer, I realized it only spit back the answers I had already given it, and then it still left the decision up to me.

Bottom line: ChatGPT recommended two versions of the same niche I already work in, but refused to actually pick one for me. So I ran the test again with a brand-new coach example, and that one taught me even more.

If we haven’t met, I’m Cass. I run Lovely Impact, where I help coaches launch and grow their businesses. Choosing a niche is one of my all-time favorite topics to coach coaches on, and it made me very curious about what AI would tell a coach about choosing a niche. Keep reading to find out what my experiments have revealed.

What I Asked ChatGPT

Let’s start with my niche. Here’s the prompt I used:

I need to pick a coaching niche. I’m a coach with a background in branding, web design, and business operations/setup. I have life, life purpose, law of attraction, manifestation and entrepreneurship coaching certifications. Tell me what the best niche is with these credentials.

Pretty short, but it has real experience in it. I wanted to know what a total stranger would make of my credentials.

Screenshot of the prompt I used to ask Chat GPT to choose my Coaching Niche

What ChatGPT Told Me

It picked one niche: Business Launch Coaching for New and Early-Stage Coaches. It also gave me two runners-up, an Entrepreneurial Mindset Coach and a Business Clarity Coach for Women Entrepreneurs.

It even wrote my niche sentence for me: “I help newly certified and early-stage coaches turn their training, ideas, and expertise into a clear, professional coaching business they’re confident launching.” After that it mapped out a process that runs from clarity to launch.

Screenshot of the coaching niches ChatGPT recommended for me

What It Got Right

Okay, credit where it’s due. It put my web design and business setup background up front and treated the life purpose and manifestation certifications as extra flavor instead of the main event. That’s the same call I’d make.

It also warned me against becoming “an all-purpose resource,” because I’d end up doing every service myself all over again. Yep.

It also told me to be careful what I promise. I can help a coach get ready to launch, but whether she lands paying clients depends on demand and her own sales, and I can’t control either one. So it suggested promising readiness and leaving first-client results out of it.

Why It Worked for Me

Now let’s talk about why it looks like AI nailed my niche.

First, there was previous reference in my ChatGPT memory about Lovely Impact and what I offer there. It basically had the answers in the back of the textbook to look up and give context to my question. It also had the background that I offered right in the prompt: “this is what my background is in.”

The AI is acting as a mirror for things I’ve already told it, not giving me answers to things I don’t already know.

So I tried again, this time writing like a brand-new coach.

What Happened When I Wrote Like a Brand-New Coach

Here’s the second prompt:

I just finished a life coaching certification and I want to start coaching. I like helping people. What niche should I pick?

This one didn’t fall apart, by the way. I expected it to. It gave good advice, like building your niche around the change you want to help someone make, and refining it once you’ve worked with a few clients. I agree with both of those.

Then it gave me five niches: confidence and self-trust, life transition, goals and accountability, purpose and career direction, and personal growth and follow-through. Every one of those is a category thousands of coaches already use. “People who second-guess themselves” is basically “women who struggle with confidence,” the weak example from my post on how to write a niche statement for coaches. And how could it do better? I didn’t give it anything specific to work with.

Screenshot of the first 3 niches recommended for a new life coach
Screenshot of the final two niches recommended for a new life coach

It also said to check whether people are actively looking for help with the problem and willing to pay for it. Great. But how do I do that? It never said.

Then it offered a four-question quiz to narrow things down. I answered like someone on day one, since that’s who this test is for. What I most enjoy helping people do: “recognize their potential and create a more fulfilling life.” Who I’d help: “I’m not sure yet.” Coaching style: “a mix of all three.” Experience: “I’m new to this and still discovering my strengths.” Those are my test answers (not real ones).

Screenshot of the quiz it asked the new coach in order to narrow a niche

Four clicks later it landed on “Purposeful Life Direction & Personal Fulfillment,” for adults who feel stuck or unfulfilled. It even had a section called “Why I’d start broad rather than choose a specific demographic.”

Some of the advice was solid. Talk to five to ten people who fit the profile and run a small pilot before you build anything. It also said to keep coaching clear of mental health treatment, which is good. But the niche itself sounded finished after four clicks, and it never told me who it was for.

What AI Couldn’t Know About Me

Back to my own result, because there’s a gap in it. ChatGPT only had my credentials. It doesn’t know my finances or my energy. It doesn’t know what I want to be doing in two years or which clients drain me.

That stuff decides your niche. A niche has to hold up against your strengths and weaknesses, and fit inside the things that energize you while avoiding the things that drain you, and a resume can’t show you that.

The Question ChatGPT Ended With

The best part of my answer was the very last paragraph. ChatGPT said I should decide, before committing, “whether you want to spend most of your coaching time helping people build and launch their businesses, or helping people understand and interrupt the patterns that keep them from taking action.”

That’s exactly the right question. It even offered to compare the two “based on your preferred day-to-day work, ideal clients, and long-term business model.”

But that’s the stuff a quick prompt can’t pull out of you. Someone has to ask the follow-up and wait through the awkward pause. AI skipped that part.

3 Checks to Run on an AI Niche

How to Check Any AI Niche Answer

Before you build anything on an AI niche answer, run it through these three checks.

  1. Can you picture one real person? Take the statement ChatGPT wrote for my brand-new coach: “I help people who feel stuck or unfulfilled gain clarity about what they want, reconnect with their potential, and take practical steps toward a life that feels more meaningful to them.” Try to picture her. You can’t. Everybody feels stuck sometimes. And a stranger couldn’t repeat it back to you.
  2. Do you want to be doing this in two years? Being able to do something and wanting to do it every week for years are different things.
  3. Can you afford to do it right now? A niche that needs a long runway doesn’t help if you need clients this quarter.

If you want the basic math behind picking a niche, I’ve got a post on how to choose a coaching niche.

When You Want a Person Instead

If you’re sitting on an AI answer and can’t tell whether it’s right, or you’re torn between two niches that both look good, you’re who my Niche Clarity session is for.

Before we meet, you fill out a short intake form and my dream client archetype worksheet. Then we spend 90 minutes on the niche you’re weighing. We go through the pros and cons and pin down the real result you help clients get. You leave with a finished niche statement and an action plan, and you get the recording too.

It’s $389. If you want to keep going after that, it credits toward my six-session launch package as long as you upgrade within two weeks. Book a Niche Clarity session here.

I’m not going to pick your niche for you. What I’m after is what’s true about how you work and who you do it best with, so you end up with a niche you believe when you say it out loud. It won’t fill your calendar on its own, because that depends on your marketing and sales too. What you’ll have is a clear niche and a plan for what to do next.

Want to work it out yourself first? The Niche Clarity Workbook for Coaches walks you through it step by step.

What I’d Do With an AI Answer

Use AI to get options on the table fast. Then test whatever it gives you against your real life and a few honest conversations.

If you’d like a person to help with that part, you can book a Niche Clarity session and we’ll sort it out together.

About The Author

Hey! I’m Cass, a Certified Life/Abundance/Business Coach and the founder of Lovely Impact. I help coaches launch their businesses with impactful coaching, and beautiful branding & websites. I'm sharing everything I've learned about building a coaching business on this blog.

By Cass

Hey! I’m Cass, a Certified Life/Abundance/Business Coach and the founder of Lovely Impact. I help coaches launch their businesses with impactful coaching, and beautiful branding & websites. I'm sharing everything I've learned about building a coaching business on this blog.

BEFORE YOU GO!Get free access to a library of resources to grow your coaching biz.

The most comprehensive coaching library online including trainings, ebooks, checklists, and more.

Intro: Business Naming Masterclass for CoachesWatch this lesson for free!

Intro: Pricing Masterclass for CoachesWatch this lesson for free!

Hey Coach! Need help?

I can help you set up & launch your coaching business, or build your website.

Step by step video instruction!Tour Our Video Library

Easy to use! No coding needed.Watch how easy it is!